Arkham Horror

Search

Aconyte

Fiction

Silver and the Stars

11.17.2026

Silver and the Stars – The Shunned Island

Silver and the Stars – The Shunned Island

Master of the occult Carl Sanford has fought monsters and Ancient Ones, only to be laid low by the powerful and mysterious Randall Tillinghast. Now, assumed dead and missing from Arkham, Sanford sets out on a European adventure with his new protege, Estrella, searching for a path toward revenge in six short stories, Silver and the Stars, by Tim Pratt. Read or listen to the first story, “The Shunned Island”, below and follow Arkham Horror on social media or subscribe to the Aconyte Fiction Podcast to catch the rest of the series.

Order of Silver Twilight icon.

Silver
and the
Stars

The Shunned Island

by Tim Pratt

“It’s a bit desolate, isn’t it?” Estrella stood in the bow of their hired boat, wearing a white dress that billowed as they cut across the Mediterranean waves. Her eyes were hidden by oversized round sunglasses that gave her the look of a predatory insect. “I thought you said this gentleman you knew was on the isle of Serifos.” 

“I should have clarified. He was somewhere in the vicinity of Serifos.” Sanford leaned on the walking stick he didn’t really need; he was host to a supernatural parasite and could have swum to the island from the mainland with the Vanquisher lending him strength. “I’ve never seen the appeal of being a hermit, but my old friend Villar is less social than I am – less social than anyone you’ll ever meet, really – and ultimately chose this place as the spot to while away his time.” 

“Is he truly immortal?” Estrella asked. 

The Vanquisher was bound by powerful rituals to prevent it from complaining, but Sanford could feel it squirm and writhe inside his mind, outraged at Sanford’s plans. “Villar is immortal so far,” Sanford corrected. “Immortality is only ever an assumption. But he was born when the ancient Greeks still worshipped at temples to Apollo over a thousand years ago, and there’s no reason to think he’ll stop living anytime soon. He’s proven shockingly resistant to death.” 

The wiry, close-mouthed captain of the small fishing boat they’d hired dropped anchor. Sanford and his apprentice Estrella would have to take a rowboat the short distance to shore – something muttered about treacherous rocks. Sanford followed Estrella, who leapt nimbly down to the dinghy. He handed her his walking stick, then lowered himself more carefully to join her. The small wooden vessel rocked beneath his feet.  

He generally refused to use the great strength and agility granted by the Vanquisher because then he would miss the power too much when it was gone, but it was nice to feel no strain when pulling the oars. Sanford had already been middle-aged when Estrella was born, and though his activities in recent months had improved his physique, he had spent decades sitting at desks and sipping cognac before that.  

There were indeed jagged rocks, treacherous spurs just beneath the surface and sometimes breaking through, but their boat was small enough to navigate the obstacles, and soon they reached a sandy beach. Estrella hopped out and pulled the rowboat up to the shore, her leather satchel swinging from her shoulder.  

Sanford looked around and had to agree with his apprentice’s assessment: desolate. The place was essentially a great hump of rock surrounded by a narrow ring of sandy beach, guarded by a necklace of submerged teeth. The only vegetation was lichen and a few tufts of scrubby grass. The island was so small it didn’t even have a name, though as he recalled the locals called it the Blighted Isle or the Shunned Island, or something like that. The Greeks had a word for everything. It was, if anything, even less inviting than the first time he’d stepped foot here. It was sadder, somehow, knowing a person lived on this rock. 

“Villar!” Sanford shouted. “I have a gift for you!” There was no reply, apart from the cry of a sea bird. 

Estrella laughed in disbelief. “Didn’t you say this man is basically a demigod? Shouting for him like that seems… disrespectful.” 

“Tut, tut. Don’t go around thinking demigods are better than you are. That’s just what they want. Come along, there’s a cave. Perhaps he’s inside.” He began to trudge across the sand. The Vanquisher twisted in silent fury inside him.  

“What does he eat? What does he drink?” Estrella took off her sunglasses, her eyes bright and curious.  

“Fish? Rain? Or nothing. Villar doesn’t require sustenance like we do.” Or as I do, anyway. He wasn’t sure about Estrella. Despite appearing to be a perfectly ordinary young woman of not yet twenty, something otherworldly lurked in her heritage, and while she had a few supernatural powers they knew about, she might have others waiting to be discovered.  

They circled the great gray rock that made up the bulk of the island until they found an opening: not a picturesque round cave mouth, but a jagged, not-quite-vertical crack in the rock just large enough to squeeze through. Sanford had only been to this island once, to set certain wards, and had never ventured into the cave.  

“Villar, blast it, are you in there?” He cocked his head to listen, and even with the Vanquisher improving his hearing, could just barely discern a croaking human voice. “Come out, man!”  

This time there was no reply. 

“It seems we must spelunk,” he said with great distaste. “Estrella, conjure us a light?” 

Sanford, who was by all accounts (especially his own) a great magus, had taken on the Spanish girl as an apprentice, and she’d proven a quick study. She murmured a few words and an orb of purple-tinged light appeared. When Sanford conjured light, it was pure white, but that twist of not-quite-human heritage in Estrella meant she could do the exact same spell and have it come out differently.  

Sanford gestured, and she preceded him into the cave, slipping through the crack. He followed, gritting his teeth. If his suit jacket got ripped, there’d be hell to pay. Soon, he emerged into the open space beyond, lit by Estrella’s magic and flickering with spectral shadows. The floor was soft sand. Cold ashes of a fire laid nearby, surrounded by driftwood logs and smooth rocks that made for makeshift seating. “Villar!” he shouted, and this time the answering cry was easier to hear.  

“I don’t see an aura,” Estrella said. She could see supernatural entities, their unnatural qualities manifesting as pillars or clouds of light.  

“Oh, Villar is human,” Sanford explained. “Immortality was something done to him. I’m sure you’ll hear about it. He likes to complain.” 

Estrella went deeper into the cave, with Sanford close behind. The rock ceiling lowered, and the walls crept in on both sides. Within moments, they found Sanford’s old friend stretched out on the sand, one leg horribly bent and twisted, a shard of exposed bone poking through the skin. Villar’s small body was even more wasted and emaciated than usual. He tried to prop himself up on one knobby elbow but screamed and fell back instead. His face was covered in a patchy beard like sickly moss, his eyes red-rimmed and rolling, and he gasped and babbled in a feverish delirium.  

Sanford tutted. “What did you do to yourself, old man?” 

“Is he all right?” Estrella crouched beside Villar. 

“Oh, he’ll be fine,” Sanford said. “In fact, this makes things easier. There’s no need to go into tedious explanations now. We can just perform the ritual of transference.” 

Estrella frowned. “Don’t you need his permission?” 

“Villar owes me a favor,” Sanford said. “And I don’t mean that in some vague friendly way. He is bound, magically, to grant me a boon, and this is the boon I require. He can’t refuse, so telling him about the ritual beforehand would just be a courtesy. Anyway, he’ll thank us, I’m sure. He’ll feel so much better after we’re done. Help me set up the ritual.” 

Estrella’s bag held candles, a knife, a jar of salt, and a brass bowl, and she unpacked them on the sand. She took a small pair of scissors and carefully cut a sample of Villar’s hair and several long, curling fingernails, cooing soothing sounds to him as he moaned. Finally, she used a small needle to harvest a few drops of blood, wincing as she inserted the tip into his finger, but Villar remained insensible, either from his illness or her deftness; she’d once been in thrall to a blood magician, and was practiced at such collection. “You said he’d need to take a potion to loosen his mind.” She looked at the twitching, moaning man doubtfully.  

“Oh, I daresay his mind is loose enough. Feverish delirium isn’t so different from the state the drugs would have engendered.” Sanford sat cross-legged beside Villar as Estrella performed the ritual, chanting the words she’d memorized phonetically (her mind was extraordinary) and lighting the candles. She burned the blood, hair, and fingernails in the bowl, sending up a wretched smoke, then nodded. Sanford took Villar’s hand; it felt like a bundle of burning sticks wrapped in wet crêpe paper.  

Estrella’s words set out the terms of the new bargain: the Vanquisher would leave Sanford’s body and would dwell instead inside Villar. The parasite would lay dormant until Villar’s natural death, and then the Vanquisher would have free use of Villar’s body for as long as it liked. The Vanquisher was bound by its nature to accept such an offer, and while normally the host had to agree as well, Sanford spoke for Villar: “He consents, by the terms of our pact.” 

Somewhere in the ruins of Sanford’s old house, far away in Arkham, Massachusetts, a letter signed in blood by Villar was now crumbling to dust, the debt repaid and the magic spent.  

The squirming in Sanford’s mind became frantic, and the magus couldn’t help but smile. The malevolent entity known as the Vanquisher of the Serpents of the Night was furious: it was going to be trapped for the duration of Villar’s life, and there was no reason to believe that Villar would ever die or even could.  

“Farewell,” Sanford said, and winced as the nest of writhing hate and gleeful hunger lodged inside his mind passed from him into Villar. The magus gasped and trembled as sweat broke out on his brow. His vision went briefly gray. When he blinked again, Estrella was holding his head in her lap, looking down at him with concern. “Are you all right?”  

“I feel a bit… hmm. I think I might have been pushing myself too hard. I didn’t notice, with the Vanquisher inside me, lending me energy.” Even when bound to silence and inaction, the parasite lent its host strength and robustness. Estrella helped Sanford sit upright, and he took a deep, steadying breath. He suddenly felt every one of his many hard-won years. 

“His leg is healing!” Estrella pointed, and indeed, Villar’s bent leg straightened, the bone submerged beneath the flesh, and the skin healed over without a scratch. 

“There are advantages to having the beast inside you,” Sanford said. “The only problem is the things it will do with your body afterward.” Sanford had made an ironclad bargain, but fools who summoned the Vanquisher without the proper restrictions found themselves possessed at irregular intervals, their bodies used to commit atrocities, their minds and glands meddled with until the host developed bloodlust and cannibalistic urges to match the parasite’s.  

Villar sat up suddenly with a scream like a teakettle, then abruptly went silent. His eyes were less red but still wild. “Carl Sanford? Is that… what took you so long, you bastard?” His voice was scratchy from disuse but outraged.  

Sanford raised an eyebrow. “So long? I was unaware we had an appointment, Villar. I’d like you to meet my associate, Estrella–” 

“Sod your associate!” the man spat, scrambling to his feet. He was barely over five feet tall, emaciated, and dressed in bloody rags speckled with sand, but he still managed to radiate ferocity. “I called for help I don’t even know how long ago! Months ago, when I first broke my leg, before the infection set in! Do you know what it’s like, to have an infection raging in your body, but it won’t kill you? There is no end, no release, it is only pain! But you ignored me!” 

Sanford pinched the bridge of his nose. “I see. I’m afraid I didn’t receive your message, old boy.” He’d left Villar with a special stone etched with a spiraling sigil, magically bound to an identical stone with the same sigil inscribed in reverse, enabling communication between the island and Sanford’s office in the Silver Twilight Lodge house. But Villar was a hermit by choice and hadn’t made contact even once in the decade since Sanford set him up here. When Sanford was forced to flee Arkham to avoid death at the hands of his enemy, Randall Tillinghast, he hadn’t bothered to take that stone with him, as he’d had more pressing concerns. “There was trouble at home, and I had to leave rather abruptly–” 

“If you never got my message, why are you here… Sanford.” Villar’s twitchy fury stilled, and he cocked his head, frowning. “You did not heal my injuries. You were never good at healing, anyway.” 

“In a sense I did,” Sanford corrected. “You weren’t coherent, I’m afraid, so I couldn’t tell you about my plans. The good news is, you’ve fulfilled your obligation to me, and are no longer under–” 

“What. Did. You. Do.” Every word was like a stone dropping into a well.  

“Tell him, Estrella. I suddenly find this whole enterprise rather tedious.” Sanford got to his feet, leaning on his walking stick – not performatively, this time – and hobbled back out of the cave to stand on the shore. He looked across the blue waters of the Mediterranean to the fuzzy greenish-brown haze of the mainland and considered his next steps. Now that he was no longer infested by an interdimensional parasite, he could resume his study of Randall Tillinghast – the man, or something – who’d upended Sanford’s life… 

Estrella came rushing out of the cave, gasping, and grabbed Sanford’s arm. “He didn’t take it well. He’s very upset.” 

Sanford sighed. “Why? He will benefit from great strength and inexhaustible reserves of energy, and the Vanquisher can’t do anything until Villar dies, which he’ll never do, so–” 

“I wanted to be alone!” Villar shouted, wriggling through the crack in the stone. “That was the whole point! That’s why I came here, after centuries in the society of dying mayflies, I needed solitude!” He pointed a finger at Sanford and snarled. “And you. First you ignore my pleas, leave me to suffer for months, and then you lodge someone else inside my mind! I cannot be alone even with my thoughts?” 

“Ah,” Sanford said. “Yes, when you put it that way, I can see how this might be a bit unpleasant for you. But really, the Vanquisher is bound, it won’t speak unless spoken to–” 

“I can feel it slithering around in my head.” Villar clutched his temples and fell to his knees. 

Sanford had no good reply for that, because he knew it was true. Even when bound to be silent and to take no action, the Vanquisher would still writhe, a sensation like roiling nausea, but inside the mind. “Tut, tut, old fellow. There’s no need to be dramatic. You’ll soon grow used to the sensation. I carried the bloody thing for weeks myself–” 

“You have bound it to me for eternity,” Villar howled. “Until my death, which will never come, because I spurned the advances of something that might have been a god, because I said I would not submit for as long as I lived, and it said, ‘then live forevermore’, and I have and I will and–” Villar lowered his hands and opened his eyes, his frantic rage suddenly gone. “Wait. It… the thing… it says I can….” Villar smiled. “It says we can renegotiate.” 

Oh, dear. “Don’t listen, Villar. That thing is a monster, its ilk has destroyed whole civilizations.” 

“I don’t care about destroying civilizations.” Villar rose. “I want to destroy you, you arrogant, conceited, pompous–”. 

“Redundant,” Sanford murmured. 

Villar shrieked, clenched his fists, and then began to change. A haze of darkness surrounded him, like an aura of shadow, and he hunched over, his shoulders twisting, his arms lengthening, his body bulking up.  

“Lobisón,” Estrella murmured.  

Sanford frowned. The werewolf of Galicia? Not quite. But certainly a transformation. The fool was letting the Vanquisher loose. “Run!” Sanford said. “Back to the boat!” 

Running was easier said than done in his worn-out state, but Estrella was a wellspring of youth and energy, and she took his arm, propelling him around the thin strand of sand. Within moments Villar and the Vanquisher were out of sight around the curve of the island. 

“Villar can’t leave the island,” Sanford gasped. “Wards set up–” 

“He’s trapped here?” Estrella said. “Why would you imprison him?” 

“He asked me to,” the magus managed, outraged at his infirmity. He didn’t have the breath to explain that Villar had grown to hate the society of other humans, their inevitable aging and decay and death both breaking his heart and reminding him of his curse, so he sought solitude. But Villar feared he would become weak and return to the mainland out of loneliness, so he’d asked to be bound here. Sanford had agreed, because having an immortal owe you a favor seemed potentially useful, as, indeed, it had been. But it occurred to Sanford now that even asking for such a thing was a sign of a deeply unsettled mind, and now that mind had access to the power of an alien conqueror… 

“Sanford!” The voice was a roar like a volcanic eruption, a comparison that seemed more apt when head-sized rocks began to rain down around them, hurled by the inhuman strength of the Vanquisher. 

The dinghy was in sight, and the fishing vessel was tantalizingly moored beyond that. There was no time to drag the rowboat out, to clamber inside, to sort out the oars, to start rowing. The Vanquisher would be upon them. “Hurry, into… the water! Swim for it! Villar can’t follow us off the island!”  

They splashed out into the shallows, wading up to their knees, and the rain of stones stopped. Sanford risked a look back to see Villar – or, anyway, a beastly, half-human shape made of writhing shadows that used to be Villar – wrapping his arms around a triangular spur of rock nearly as large as a person, its roots sunk deep into the ground.  

But not deep enough. With a roar, the beast tore the stone out of the ground and then lifted the jagged boulder over its head. 

“Protection!” Sanford shouted, and Estrella moved her hands and murmured, a faint purple light appearing around her rapidly twitching fingers, to create a field of force to deflect the stone. 

But Villar didn’t throw the rock at them. Instead, he hurled it in a great, high arc… to smash down on the fishing boat beyond, where it crashed with a sound like thunder. The ship rocked and immediately began to list to one side, rapidly taking on water. Even if they swam out there now, the sinking vessel wouldn’t do them any good, and they could only dodge falling stones while treading water for so long.  

“Estrella.” Sanford put his hand on her shoulder. “We’re in a difficult situation. I would never ask this, but–” 

Suddenly, tendrils of black smoke wrapped around Sanford’s body and yanked him out of the shallows, flinging him down on the sand, where he landed hard enough to knock all the wind out of him. He rolled over on his back to look up at Villar approaching, his body entirely hidden in a roiling suit of smoke, tentacles of darkness writhing around him like deep sea worms. “Magus.” The word had strange harmonics, spoken in the doubled voice of Sanford’s old immortal friend and newer immortal enemy. “I will eat you very slowly, starting with your feet. I can make it last for days.” 

“I am so sorry.” Estrella’s voice was low and sorrowful, and Sanford and Villar both – or all three? – turned their heads to see her come walking out of the shallows. “Sanford, don’t look.” 

He rolled over to put his face in the sand and shut his eyes. 

“What do you mean she’s a–” a voice that was purely Villar’s said. There was a flash that showed purple even through Sanford’s closed lids, and the distant sound of frantic piping. 

Then silence and darkness returned, and Sanford rolled over. His apprentice knelt in the sand, head bowed, weeping softly. There was no sign of Villar or the Vanquisher. 

Estrella was not entirely human. She had a connection to another place – another plane, another dimension, or perhaps just a distant and twisted galaxy in their own universe. Strange entities dwelt there, playing atonal music on alien instruments, howling in mindless mirth, dancing as the stars and planets danced, implacable and eternal. Those entities were, in a sense, Estrella’s distant relatives, and she could open a door within herself to that frantic void and send things through. Where exactly those things went, and what happened to them once they got there, was unknown, but it seemed in every case to be a one-way trip. 

It was powerful magic, and Estrella’s greatest natural power. But there was a cost. 

Sanford crawled to her and held her in his arms. He was not a fatherly person, but he was fond of Estrella, and it grieved him to see her suffer. 

“The music,” she murmured, crying into his shoulder. “I can hear it more clearly every time I open the door. It’s calling to me, calling me home. But how? How could I go? How could I go there, when I would have to climb through myself…” 

“Shhh,” he said. “It’s all right. You are here. This is your world. That place has no claim on you. You can decide. You can choose. You can stay.” 

She sobbed a little longer, then sat up, and wiped her eyes. “I wish Villar hadn’t made me do that.”  She elbowed Sanford in the side and almost smiled. “I wish you’d had a better plan.” 

“In hindsight, I can admit that I failed to consider every potential consequence,” the magus replied.  

Then the fishing boat captain came sputtering out of the surf, eyes wide. He looked around the shunned island and crossed himself.  

“Oh, you lived,” Sanford said. “Good. You can help row us to the mainland.” 

Order of Silver Twilight icon.

Eager for more? Start at the beginning of Carl Sanford’s adventures with Master of Twilight, the Carl Sanford omnibus, collecting the novels The Ravening Deep, Herald of Ruin, and The Twilight Magus as well as the complete short story series, Silver and the Stars. Ask for it wherever you buy books or find a retailer here.

Share

Similar Topics

Aconyte

Fiction

How to Make Your Haunted House the Best on the Block

With All Hallow’s Eve upon us, perchance you find yourself seeking tips from an experienced host on how to stage a haunted house that will have all your neighbors dying to take a look inside. Look no further than the expert advice contained within Dr. Dellaluna’s most recent editorial, published in Hidden Arts of the […]

Read more

Aconyte

Alike Indignity

Card Games

Fiction

Alike Indignity – Chapter Six

Previously on Alike Indignity, Olive Sapinska, Zelda Meiger, and Talcott in Junior’s body have all been kidnapped by members and associates of the Sheldon gang. The gals overpower the brute guarding them with some quick thinking, then turn their attention to Talcott-turned-Junior to set things right. Meet the scions of the Meiger and Husserl families […]

Read more

Aconyte

Alike Indignity

Card Games

Fiction

Alike Indignity – Chapter Five

Previously on Alike Indignity, nursemaid and former Silver Twilight Lodge initiate Olive Sapinska accidentally recruits Zelda Meiger to help her track down Talcott in Junior’s body before the Sheldon gang do. But on their way to the train station, the Sheldon gang catches up with them, first. Meet the scions of the Meiger and Husserl […]

Read more

Arkham Horror
Newsletter

Register for FREE to access exclusive content and get early alerts and access to exclusive products.

News image News image
Cookie Preferences